Skip to primary navigationSkip to main contentSkip to footer
J. Anthony Jewelers logo
  • BRIDAL
    Engagement Rings
    Search Loose DiamondsBuild Your Own RingShop Engagement RingsBridal Sets
    Wedding Bands
    Women's Wedding BandsAnniversary BandsRing InsertsMen's Wedding Bands
    Education
    The 4C's of DiamondsAnniversary Gift IdeasChoosing the Right SettingDiamond Buying Guide
  • Diamonds
    Search Diamonds
    Round Princess Emerald Asscher Radiant
    Cushion Oval Pear Marquise Heart
    Jewelry & Watches
    Fashion RingsEarringsPendants & NecklacesBraceletsWatches
    Education
    The 4C's of DiamondsCaring for Diamond JewelryDiamond Buying Tips
  • Collections
    Add-A-PearlAllison KaufmanCitizenDiamond Marriage Symbol
    Frederic DuclosJewelry InnovationsLeslie'sMaster IJO Jeweler
    OstbyeOvernightParleRare & Forever
    Royal ChainSeriniumStullerUnique Settings
  • All Jewelry
    Bridal
    Engagement RingsWomen's BandsAnniversary BandsMen's BandsBridal Sets
    Rings
    Diamond FashionGemstoneGoldSilverFamily
    Earrings
    DiamondGemstoneGoldSilverJackets
    Pendants
    & Necklaces
    DiamondGemstoneGoldSilverReligious
    Bracelets
    DiamondGemstoneGoldSilverReligious
    Accessories
    & More
    AnkletsChainsPins
  • Custom
  • Our Store
    Our Store
    About UsContact UsEducationSocial MediaTestimonials
    Services
    Cleaning & InspectionsCorporate GiftsFinancingGold & Diamond BuyingJewelry AppraisalsJewelry EngravingRing Resizing
    Repairs
    Jewelry RepairsJewelry RestorationPearl & Bead RestringingRhodium PlatingTip & Prong RepairWatch Repairs
J. Anthony Jewelers logo
Log In My Cart (0)
  • Toggle Search Menu
  • Toggle My Account Menu
  • Toggle My Wishlist

From silos and dentures to diamonds and gold...

     J. Anthony Jewelers has a captivating history. Before becoming renowned jewelers, Joe and Amy Ziemba embarked on unexpected career paths. Joe, a graduate of Marquette University with a degree in Marketing, started in the industrial silo industry. Amy, with a degree in Dental Technology from MATC, honed her craft creating dental moldings.

     A change of course led them to Florida, where a new chapter began. With Joe’s entrepreneurial spirit and Amy’s artistic talent, they transitioned from their previous careers to the world of jewelry. Their shared passion for beauty and design ignited a spark that would eventually lead them back to their Wisconsin roots.

     In 1987, Joe and Amy purchased Faye's Fine Jewelry in downtown Neenah, marking the beginning of their jewelry store journey. Their dedication to exceptional customer service and Amy's exquisite craftsmanship quickly gained them a loyal following.

     Fast forward to 1998 with the move to a free-standing building, J. Anthony Jewelers was born. With their son, Benjamin, learning by their side, the family jewelry legacy continued to grow. Today, we carry on the tradition of excellence established by Joe and Amy, while embracing the future of jewelry design and customer experience.

     Benjamin, our visionary leader, inherited a passion for the entire world of jewelry—from gemstones to diamonds and everything in between. A lifelong Fox Valley resident, Benjamin embodies the heart and soul of our community. He acquired the business from his parents in 2021, bringing fresh perspectives and a renewed commitment to our customers.

     Proud of his family’s jewelry legacy in Neenah, Benjamin is dedicated to carrying on the J. Anthony Jewelers tradition of excellence. His deep-rooted connection to the craft and a passion for creating lasting memories have made him a respected jeweler and businessman. His leadership infuses J. Anthony Jewelers with a contemporary spirit while honoring our rich heritage.

     At J. Anthony Jewelers, our customers are our top priority. We believe in treating every individual with honesty, courtesy, and respect. Our commitment to fair and reasonable pricing on our fine jewelry and services sets us apart. As long-time residents of Neenah, we value our community and strive to maintain the highest ethical standards.

     We pride ourselves on our straightforward pricing policy. You won't find any haggling or constant discounts at J. Anthony Jewelers. Our goal is to provide transparency and trust in every transaction.

     Discover the J. Anthony Jewelers difference. Visit our store in Neenah or explore our collection online. Let us help you find the perfect piece to cherish for a lifetime.

Contact Us
J. Anthony Jewelers Neenah, WI

Meet Our Staff

Benjamin Ziemba 2nd Generation Owner - Designer J. Anthony Jewelers Neenah, WI

Benjamin Ziemba

2nd Generation Owner - Designer

Amy Ziemba Co-Founder - Goldsmith J. Anthony Jewelers Neenah, WI

Amy Ziemba

Co-Founder - Goldsmith

Joesph Ziemba Co-Founder - Goldsmith, Designer J. Anthony Jewelers Neenah, WI

Joseph Ziemba

Co-Founder - Goldsmith, Designer

J. Anthony Jewelers Neenah, WI
Read Now
Store Location
220 South Commercial Street
Neenah, WI 54956
(920) 729-1642
Store Information
Store Hours
Mon - Fri:9:30am - 5:30pm
Sat - Sun:Closed
Categories
  • Bridal
  • Rings
  • Earrings
  • Pendants & Necklaces
  • Bracelets
  • Watches
  • Anklets
  • Pins
  • Chains
  • Semi-mount Rings
  • Women's Diamond Rings
  • Fashion Necklaces
  • Wrap Rings
  • Wedding Sets
  • Fashion Bracelets
  • Bangle Bracelets
  • Fashion Pendants
  • Semi-mount Engagement Rings
Designers
  • Add-A-Pearl
  • Allison Kaufman
  • Citizen
  • Diamond Marriage Symbol
  • Frederic Duclos
  • Jewelry Innovations
  • Leslie's
  • Master IJO Jeweler
  • Ostbye
  • Overnight
  • Parle
  • Rare & Forever
  • Royal Chain
  • Serinium
  • Stuller
  • Unique Settings
Customer Care
  • Create an Account
  • About Us
  • Custom Design
  • Our Services
  • Testimonials
Our Newsletter

Signup for special offers and discounts.

Follow Us

© 2025 J. Anthony Jewelers. All Rights Reserved. Website designed, maintained, and hosted by  Punchmark.

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Accessibility Statement

My Bag

Learn how we use cookies in our Privacy Policy or manage cookie preferences.